Regional aspects for assessing the effectiveness of resources management in medical organizations

Introduction. Problems of assessing the healthcare system effectiveness and medical organizations, in particular, are largely associated with the fact that most studies are based on the data approved according to the established procedure in forms of federal statistical observation that do not correspond to the regional characteristics of the medical care organization.

Aim. To assess the effectiveness of personnel management in medical organizations of the Moscow healthcare system which provide primary health care to the adult population, directly involved in the provision of medical services, and the usage of generally accepted statistical indicators for this purpose.

Materials and Methods. The study is based on the analysis of the effectiveness of personnel management in medical organizations of Moscow healthcare system, selected by typological sampling according to the given parameters, carried out in the context of the relevant groups of medical workers (doctors and nurses) in the following areas: number, composition, training level, movement, workload, etc.

Results. Analyzing the effectiveness of personnel management, as the most important element of the resourceful basis in medical organizations, the authors considered the aspects connected with the formation of the staff directly involved in the provision of medical services in accordance with federal regulatory legal acts and regional requirements for primary health care organization. The results of the study confirm that under the circumstances of healthcare system decentralization, current forms of federal statistical observation do not correspond to the regional characteristics of the healthcare organization system and that deficiency of primary data from medical organizations excludes the possibility of forming long-term forecasts in a healthcare system of subjects of the Russian Federation.

Conclusion. The lack of uniform approaches governing the analysis and assessment of the effective resource management processes in medical organizations, the imperfection of existing statistical information for such purposes, and the importance of accounting for regional characteristics of the healthcare organization require searching for tools that can objectively assess the effectiveness of medical organizations, including the organizational specifics of medical care provision.

1. The World Health Organization. Health system effectiveness: ways to increase the importance of quantitative assessment as a tool for managers and developers. Copenhagen. 2018; 264 p. (in Russ)

2. Dyachenko V.G., Solokhina V.G., Dyachenko S.V. [Quality management of medical care]. Textbook. Publishing House of the Far Eastern State Medical University. 2013; 696 p. (in Russ).

3. Volkova O. A. On the issue of improving the efficiency of resource management of medical organizations operating in the field of public health. Proceedings of the Research Institute of health organization and medical management. 2019; 1: 31-35 (in Russ).

4. Khalfin R. A., Orlov S. A., Madyanova V. V., Stolbov A. P., Kachkova O. E. Modern approaches to evaluating the effectiveness of using health resources (review). Problems of standardization in healthcare. 2020; 3 (4): 3-12 (in Russ). https://doi.org/10.26347/1607-2502202003-04003-012.

5. Order of the Moscow Department of health dated 02.04.2014 No. 305 «On conducting a pilot project to implement the quality Standard for resource management in state institutions subordinate to the Moscow Department of Health» (together with the «program for improving the quality of resource management», «List of state institutions subordinate to the Moscow Department of health participating in the pilot project to implement the quality Standard for resource management in state institutions of Moscow»). Consultant plus. [Electronic resource]. (in Russ) URL: https://docs7.online-sps.ru/cgi/online.cgi?req=doc&ts=197125167307144516433654664&cacheid=9CF0D2473FC2082E0CF9479AC0B9C173&mode=splus&base=MLAW&n=156143&rnd=FAD535C971A6B911A4C9F8001EE1A46F#04066478249889709. Аccessed: 05.08.2020

6. Boychenko Yu. Ya., Budarin S. S., Nikonov E. L., Assessment of the quality of resource management in outpatient clinics of the state health system of Moscow. Bulletin Of Roszdravnadzor. 2018; 2: 57-64 (in Russ).

7. Alexandrov M. A. Assessment of personnel potential in healthcare. Chief medical officer. 2018; 2 (in Russ). [Electronic resource]. URL: http://управление-здравоохранением.рф/publ/kadry/ocenka_kadrovogo_potenciala_v_zdravookhranenii/16-1-0-843. Аccessed: 05.08.2020.

8. Rosstat Order № 483 dated 03.08.2018 "On approval of statistical tools for the organization by the Ministry of health of the Russian Federation of Federal statistical surveillance in the field of health protection". Consultant plus. (in Russ) [Electronic resource]. URL: https://docs7.online-sps.ru/cgi/online.cgi?req=doc&cacheid=A295B87BF88C0D6C3131122944EC833E&mode=docs&SORTTYPE=0&BASENODE=1&base=LAW&n=308829. Аccessed: 20.08.2020.

9. Rosstat Order №. 773 dated 24.12.2018 "On approval of Federal statistical observation forms with instructions on how to fill them out for the organization by the Ministry of health of the Russian Federation of Federal statistical observation in the field of health protection". Consultant plus (in Russ). [Electronic resource]. URL: https://docs7.online-sps.ru/cgi/online.cgi?req=doc&ts=130880005506172257058699009&cacheid=4BE1D8B3E0ECB74427C8CE1C63B9FC79&mode=splus&base=LAW&n=341682&rnd=8A9BD35495914B0B85462247727A98C0#007297461314432074. Аccessed: 12.08.2020.

10. Order of the Ministry of health of the Russian Federation of 06.03.2015 N 87n"about the unified form of medical documentation and the form of statistical reporting used when carrying out medical examinations of certain groups of the adult population and preventive medical examinations, orders for their filling". Consultant plus (in Russ). [Electronic resource]. URL: https://docs7.online-sps.ru/cgi/online.cgi7req=doc&ts=130880005506172257058699009&cacheid=C2AF1F8F20CAA995360F6E58C791E33C&mode=splus&base=LAW&n=177894&rnd=8A9BD35495914B0B85462247727A98C0#041415999465955866. Accessed: 12.08.2020.

11. Resolution Of the government of Moscow of 27.12.2018 № 1703-PP "on the Territorial program of state guarantees of free medical care to citizens in the city of Moscow for 2019 and for the planning period of 2020 and 2021". Consultant plus (in Russ). [Electronic resource]. URL: https://docs7.online-sps.ru/cgi/online.cgi?req=doc&ts=175183139905335443002079971&cacheid=CD1EF3AF486F483337DC1A4E0568FE78&mode=splus&base=MLAW&n=198095&rnd=E844C576C85F9570DA8B7AF95ED88F88#03227815038012394. Accessed: 10.08.2020.

12. Order of the Ministry of health and social development of Russia dated 15.05.2012 № 543n "on approval of the Regulations on the organization of primary health care for adults". Consultant plus (in Russ). [Electronic resource]. URL: https://docs7.online-sps.ru/cgi/online.cgi?req=doc&ts=175183139905335443002079971&cacheid=CCEAB21D6DEE01C3914B211AE7A1523E&mode=splus&base=LAW&n=358683&rnd=E844C576C85F9570DA8B7AF95ED88F88#04698315633072836. Accessed: 10.08.2020.

13. Order of the Ministry of health of Russia from 29.03.2019 № 177 "On approval of methods of calculation of targets and additional indicators of the national project "Health" (together with "Methodology for calculating target indicator "the Staffing level in the units providing care in the outpatient setting (individuals in the plurality 1,2), %", "methods of calculation of the target indicator "share of posts of paramedical staff in the departments, the number of specialists involved in the system of continuing education of medical workers, including those using distance education technologies (thousands), who provide medical care in outpatient settings (individuals with a coefficient of 1.2),%", "the methodology for calculating the target indicator". People)", "Methodology for calculating the target indicator" Coverage of all citizens with preventive medical examinations,%", "Methodology for calculating the additional indicator" Coverage of children aged 15-17 years of preventive medical examinations with the aim of preserving their reproductive health (proportion of the total number of children subject to inspections), %", "methods of calculation of the target indicator "Number of settlements with a population of over 100 people to 2,000 people, according to geographic information system, Ministry of health of Russia, outside the zone of accessibility from the medical organization or its structural unit providing primary health care, units," "Method of calculation of the target indicator "Share of medical organizations, participating in the creation and replication of the "New model of medical organizations providing primary health care" from the total number of medical organizations providing this type of care,%", "the Methodology for calculating the target indicator" Increase in the volume of exports of medical services by at least 4 times compared to 2017 (up to 1 billion us dollars) by 2024"). Consultant Plus (in Russ). [Electronic resource]. URL: https://docs7.online-sps.ru/cgi/online.cgi?req=doc&ts=175183139905335443002079971&cacheid=E1AF8AADB8836554799ADE4C8544ACA3&mode=splus&base=LAW&n=322581&rnd=E844C576C85F9570DA8B7AF95ED88F88#031557281550039296. Accessed: 10.08.2020.

14. Protocol of the Presidium of the Council under the President of the Russian Federation for strategic development and priority projects dated 26.07.2017 № 8 "Passport of the priority project " Providing healthcare with qualified specialists"". Consultant plus (in Russ). [Electronic resource]. URL: https://docs7.online-sps.ru/cgi/online.cgi7req=doc&ts=175183139905335443002079971&cacheid=09C9BC357137356DDF5247AA779DF91B&mode=splus&base=LAW&n=222125&rnd=E844C576C85F9570DA8B7AF95ED88F88#05700680802647764. Accessed: 10.08.2020.

15. Order of the Moscow Department of health of 20.12.2012 No. 1470 "on optimization of work on making an appointment with a doctor in electronic form". Consultant plus (in Russ). [Electronic resource]. URL: https://docs7.online-sps.ru/cgi/online.cgi?req=doc&ts=197125167307144516433654664&cacheid=00E305B26BE881B74527215656705846&mode=splus&base=MLAW&n=179614&rnd=FAD535C971A6B911A4C9F8001EE1A46F#06588786883044451. Accessed: 12.08.2020.

16. Order of the Moscow Department of health from 06.04.2016 № 293 " on approval of Methodological recommendations for the implementation of the "Moscow standard of polyclinics" and criteria for assessing the sustainability of its implementation"(together with the " Regulations for the implementation of measures to provide planned medical care at home to patients with disabilities) the ability to move independently and / or self-serve due to diseases, the consequences of injuries or defects in medical organizations"). Consultant plus (in Russ). [Electronic resource]. URL: https://docs7.online-sps.ru/cgi/online.cgi?req=doc&ts=130880005506172257058699009&cacheid=6F0BBDC59AC377DD413BD5E81B081933&mode=splus&base=MLAW&n=199880&rnd=8A9BD35495914B0B85462247727A98C0#009462503549650614. Accessed: 12.08.2020. (in Russ).

17. Volkova O. A., Smirnova E. V. Quality of human resource management of a medical organization - as an element of the strategy of continuous improvement of the quality of medical care. Problems of standardization in healthcare. 2018; no. 3 (4): 3-18. (in Russ). https://doi.org/10.26347/1607-2502201803-04003-011.

18. Volkova O. A., Smirnova E. V. Effectiveness of dispensary surveillance as an element of the global strategy to combat chronic non-communicable diseases. Proceedings of the Research Institute of health organization and medical management. 2019; 2: 38-43 (in Russ).

19. Order of the Ministry of health of the Russian Federation No. 144 dated 21.03.2019 "on approval of the departmental target program " Analysis and monitoring of the health system". Consultant plus (in Russ). [Electronic resource]. URL: https://docs7.online-sps.ru/cgi/online.cgi?req=doc&ts=197125167307144516433654664&cacheid=4DD899ABB3E37E05D7328B5F31373311&mode=splus&base=LAW&n=356209&rnd=FAD535C971A6B911A4C9F8001EE1A46F#0734852903435232. Accessed: 12.08.2020.

20. Order of the Ministry of health of the Russian Federation No. 834n dated 15.12.2014 "on approval of unified forms of medical documentation used in medical organizations that provide medical care on an outpatient basis, and the procedures for filling them out". Information and legal portal Garant (in Russ). [Electronic resource]. URL: https://base.garant.ru/70877304/. Accessed: 14.08.2020.

21. Mikhailova Yu. V., Leonov S. A., Son I. M., Pogorelova E. I., et al. Current state and ways of development of national medical statistics. "Social aspects of public health", 2007, no. 1 (in Russ) [Electronic resource]. URL: http://vestnik.mednet.ru/content/view/21/30. Accessed 12.08.2020).

22. Gokhberg L. M., Kuznetsova T. E., Abdrakhmanova G. I. and others. A promising model of state statistics in the digital age. XIX April international. scientific conference on problems of economic and social development. Moscow. 2018. 500 p. (in Russ).